San Jose Mercury News
Skeptics examine Sept. 11
ABOUT 100 GATHER IN S.F. FOR ALTERNATIVE INQUIRY
Posted on Sat, Mar. 27, 2004
By Dana Hull
Mercury News
High-level advisers from the Clinton and
Bush administrations testified before the commission investigating
the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks in Washington, D.C., this
week.
Now a growing subculture of skeptics, amateur
sleuths and independent researchers of all stripes are
questioning the ``official narrative'' of Sept. 11, and
about 100 people are gathering in San Francisco this weekend
for a three-day inquiry of their own.
It's easy to dismiss the self-proclaimed
``911 Truth Movement'' as little more than conspiracy
theorists gone overboard.
But the movement, which until recently largely
lived on the Internet, is increasingly holding public
forums and attracting attention from the mainstream media.
The weekend event, at the Herbst Theatre
in San Francisco, includes panel discussions about Al-Qaida's
links to the CIA, the history of covert operations, and
the role of Pakistan in Sept. 11. Some of the more incredible
theories say that the planes never hit the World Trade
Center towers but that the towers were destroyed by remote
control; others insist that some of the hijackers are
still alive. The Internet is filled with Web sites like
www.911 review.org and www.911 sharethetruth.com, many
of which argue that Sept. 11 was an elaborately planned
hoax.
Part II of the ``International Inquiry Into
9-11'' will take place in Toronto on Memorial Day weekend.
The conference, which began Friday and continues
through Sunday, comes as the events of that day are still
fresh in the public's mind. The official inquiry in Washington,
D.C., has drawn widespread attention. As it began, Richard
Clarke, a former counterterrorism expert, published a
book saying that President Bush ordered him to look for
a link between Iraq and the Sept. 11 attacks.
The official Sept. 11 commission has largely
focused on warning signs that a terrorist attack was in
the works and who in the Bush and Clinton administrations
was aware of those warnings.
Different theories
But they have stayed far away from questions
such as ``What happened to the fifth jetliner and the
hijackers on it?'' (The ``fifth jetliner'' theory stems
from early news reports on the morning of Sept. 11 that
five, not four, planes were unaccounted for.)
The timing of the San Francisco event is
no coincidence.
``We want our inquiry to go on before the
official inquiry comes to their own conclusions,'' said
Carol Brouillet, a Palo Alto mother of three who is organizing
this weekend's events. Brouillet, 46, is a longtime local
peace activist, and she says that she wants the public
to have a chance to hear from a variety of researchers.
Ellen Mariani of New Hampshire, whose husband,
Louis Neil Mariani, died when United Airlines Flight 175
was flown into the south tower of the World Trade Center,
is a cult hero to many, in part because her participation
in the ``truth'' conferences gives the group some legitimacy.
Mariani has filed a lawsuit against Bush
and other White House officials that charges them with
complicity in the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks.
``My husband was on his way to our daughter's
wedding, and he never made it,'' said a tearful Mariani
at Friday's news conference at the Herbst Theatre. ``Mr.
Bush, I am ashamed of our government. They have lied.''
Growing doubts
The Internet has allowed Sept. 11 theories
to spread like wildfire. And growing public concern about
the government's rationale for the war in Iraq has fueled
further speculation.
``The Iraq war really increased the interest
in Sept. 11 conspiracy theories,'' said Kathryn Olmstead,
a history professor at the University of California-Davis
who is writing a book called ``Governing Conspiracies.''
``It's morphed into one: The government
set up Sept. 11 so they could go into Iraq so they can
control the oil. There was a small number of activists
who were suspicious from the start, and then once the
anti-war movement got going a lot of people who were opposed
to the war wondered if there was a link. But there are
some serious people who are genuinely concerned that their
government is hiding information from them.''
IF YOU'RE INTERESTED
For more information about this weekend's
conference, go to www.911inquiry.org. Tickets are available
through City Box Office at (415) 392-4400. |